Home Blog Page 1302

Beast Review: Meaner, Leaner, Weaker, Can You Make It Any Worser?

Nelson Dilipkumar’s Vijay-starrer BEAST starts off in a literal Beast mode where we see Veeraraghavan (Vijay), a well-informed and well-resourced Indian RAW agent, cleaning up the terrorists holed up in a mansion like a pack of cards.

We see some exceptional action choreography and stunt sequences during this stretch where we see Veeraraghavan slaying the terrorists, literally.

There were numerous instances where we sit in awe of the brilliant stunt choreography, and what better than our own Thalapathy to be at the helm of it, jumping and swaying from one end of the building to the other, handling the guns and knifes like a pair of bamboo sticks.

I quite liked how the movie did not have a “special” introduction scene to the star, which registered the fact that this wasn’t a usual Vijay movie that we are going to witness. This introduction setup was like a Bond character introduction where we see a one-man show kind of a sequence. Incidentally, Veera gets called the Indian James Bond. The movie then moves to a mall in Chennai being taken control by the terrorists, and we see a reluctant (PTSD suffering) Veera agreeing to help the Indian Government on one condition.

I loved the premise that shows the root cause for Veera’s PTSD where a small girl is considered to be just collateral damage by the agency for an ongoing operation but how it turns out to be a huge loss for the girl’s family. This is a great plotline for a movie of such tonality, an angle from which we do not see terrorism much and how it actually affects even the people involved in it. That’s how the movie started off, in fact, but once the mall hijack was set up, this potentially better plot was let loose.

The movie starts showing signs of feebleness during the mall hijack as it takes longer to set things up, but during this setup, we at least see the Nelson-esque comedy with VTV Ganesh in top form.

VTV Ganesh’s one-liners are rollicking, it reminded me of his performance in Vinnaithandi Varuvaaya. Selvaraghavan‘s Altaf was indeed a different one, his voice and his mannerism perfectly suited the sarcasm. The restricted comedy from Yogi Babu and Redin Kingsley was terrific but needed a lot more from all of them together. There was a brilliant opportunity to do a comedy of errors kind of a thing here, something along the lines of what we saw in that exceptionally staged Metro train fight sequence in Doctor. The brilliance of Kolamaavu Kokila was that it involved utilizing the maximum comic potential of Anbudasan and Yogi Babu, and similarly, in Doctor, we get stellar comic timing by Redin Kingsley, Yogi Babu, Shiva Aravind and Sunil Reddy (Killi-Maahali combo). I was pretty excited to see the Killi-Maahali combo here in Beast as well, it meant that it was in the same Nelson universe, but those two were criminally underutilized.

Beast tries too hard to seamlessly juggle between being a funny-spoof movie and a serious action thriller, but the transition isn’t as seamless as it was intended. What worked brilliantly in Doctor did not work here for the sole reason that a big star has come into the world of Nelson. When a big star like Vijay comes in, everything gets bigger and scaled up to massive levels. It is required to have elevation sequences just for the sake of having it, which dilutes the narrative if it isn’t a strong one like Beast. At one end, we see an indestructible Veera counter-attacking every terrorist plan with so much “conviction”, but suddenly he dodges 100 bullets and hit 7 men with just 7 bullets of a shotgun. On the other hand, we see the Selvaraghavan character joking with the terrorists during his negotiation, and at one point we even see the main head of the hijacker group give up his ongoing hijack. The worst of all, we see the head of the terrorist group shown as a dwarf. I am sure all this was done to be light-hearted, funny and spoof-kind, but the plot is lost while focusing more on the transition from serious to funny mode than focusing on the movie’s highs and lows.

The audience starts thinking about the logic and the loopholes only when they do not connect with the characters. There needs to be an emotional core for the audience to connect to, which eventually would drive the movie. I would have wanted more of Veera’s PTSD suffering to take centerstage and eventually act as leverage for the character to overcome, which would have been that “low” for Veera and then come out with the much needed “high”. When the emotions are at the right amounts, people do not have time to think about the logic, as they are already invested in your characters and have started rooting for them to win. This issue was addressed extraordinarily in Payanam movie (a flight hijack movie led by Nagarjuna, directed by Radha Mohan). We get invested so much in the emotions of the flight passengers that we forget the logical loopholes even if there were any. Eventually, we know that the Nagarjuna character will succeed with the mission, but the suspense was maintained brilliantly through the emotions of the characters.

Beast could have been something extraordinary had Nelson taken a little more care in setting up that emotional core, instead of conveniently tweaking his story to cater to the star power. I am sure he will come back stronger to his forte of dark comedy, he just needs to back his strong suit and not budge to the star power and other external factors, and write something that would fit any star into this universe of his.

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

Save Soil Movement: Cycle Awareness Rally on Soil Conservation arrives in Coimbatore

Twenty-seven cyclists arrived in Coimbatore today on a bicycle rally that commenced from Bengaluru to raise awareness about soil conservation. The cyclists said they undertook the rally in support of the global Movement to Save Soil, launched last month by Sadhguru, Founder-Isha Foundation.

“Soil fertility is declining rapidly worldwide. Scientists and UN researchers say that if we do not take action now to restore the declining soil fertility, we will not be able to farm after the next 40-50 years,” they said explaining why they embarked on the cycle rally. “Isha founder Sadhguru has started a movement to protect the soil, urging the nations of the world to enact appropriate laws in this regard. To this end, at the age of 65, he is traveling 30,000 km on a motorcycle from London through 27 countries to raise awareness among the people,” they added stating that this inspired them to contribute to awareness generation in their own capacity.

The team, Pedal Pushers, includes veterans, IT employees, and members of the medical profession. “We started this cycle rally yesterday. We cycled about 420 km from Bangalore to Isha Yoga Center in Coimbatore to create awareness among the public,” they said.

The rally was organized in Bengaluru by music composer Shri. Chandan Shetty and actor Niveda Gowda who flagged off the rally from Bengaluru. 

Departing from there, they reached Coimbatore via Hosur, Krishnagiri, Salem and Erode and completed their journey at Isha Yoga Center.

(This is an official press release from Isha Foundation. The Commune was not involved in creating this content.)

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

An honest opinion about ‘honest CM’ Kejriwal

arvind kejriwal covid

Aam Aadmi Party National Convenor became Delhi Chief Minister championing to end the politics of “power through money and money through power”.

But that has now undergone a complete change.

Today, the AAP’s politics can be defined as – ‘power through freebies and freebies through power’.

Votebank and freebie politics is what defines Kejriwal and his AAP which poses a massive threat to our country.

Kejriwal is one of the foremost insincere individuals in Indian politics. His thirst for power has no bounds.

Ever since he tasted electoral success in the Delhi Legislative Assembly elections in 2013, he appears to be the most serpentine man for India’s democratic institution. The man also seems to have aspirations to become the Prime Minister of India.

The man who has been quite vocal about the fact that he has come to change Indian politics has changed Indian politics for the vile.

Kejriwal and his party aren’t the saints they claim to be and are sinister who should be called for the sake of public good.

Whenever he feels that he’s losing his credibility, Kejriwal can sit on a dharna to hoodwink people. From irresponsible announcment of freebies to the pathetic state of Mohalla Clinics, his oxygen cylinder scam during COVID crisis to his false claims of building schools, colleges and hospital, Kejriwals failure is a never-ending list.

On the other, a person like Kejriwal has the audacity on commenting on national security affairs is astounding! Who is Kejriwal to say that India should stop purchasing arms from Israel? Does he even understand foreign policy?

Kejriwal belongs to those class of politicians who asked for proofs when the surgical strikes happened. By saying so he amplified Pakistan’s propaganda within India undermining the valour of our armed forces. He remains primarily responsible for letting Shaheenbagh protests turn into the Delhi Riots as it was Tahir Hussain an MLA from his party who ‘wanted to teach a lesson to the Hindus’. The farmers protests wouldn’t have stretched for over a year had it not been tacitly supported by Kejriwal’s AAP.

Arvind Kejriwal is as shrewd as he can get and he very well knows how to play the victim card through his melodrama and theatricals. During the peak of the second wave of the COVID pandemic, Kejriwal government in Delhi resorted to blaming the Centre for unavailability of oxygen in Delhi. In fact, he had had demanded four times the medical oxygen that was required for Delhi.

But his narrative of cynicism just doesn’t hold water in front of a leader with an idealistic approach and a nationalist vision.

One thing is certain: the Kejriwal has altered Indian politics in unprecedented ways.

Given that AAP has now made its entry into Punjab, it is time that people realize the hazard he is.

(Views expressed here are the author’s own)

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

‘Dravidian Stockists’ abuse Maestro Ilaiyaraaja for praising PM Modi’s development initiatives

Musical maestro ‘Isagnani‘ Ilaiyaraaja finds himself at the receiving end of attacks by ‘Dravidian Stockists’ and ‘Ambedkarites’ for his comments praising Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Maestro Ilaiyaraaja has written the foreword for the book ‘Ambedkar & Modi – Reformer’s Ideas, Performer’s Implementation’ brought out by Blue Graph Digital Foundation.

The book is said to be an academic attempt to bring to light Dr. Ambedkar’s vision and work across domains, and how New India under Prime Minister Modi is furthering Ambedkar’s ideals

In his foreword for the book, Ilaiyaraaja describes Dr. Ambedkar as a rare leader “who made history during his own times and is still being read and followed widely, decades after his time”.

Quoting Prime Miniter Narendra Modi’s speech that he gave in 2016, Ilaiyaraaja throws light on the incident when PM Modi called Dr. Ambedkar the architect of India’s water policy.

Ilaiyaraaja also lauds PM Modi’s development initiatives in the book saying that the the Prime Minister’s ‘Make in India’ project has paved way for world class infrastructure such as roads, railways, metro rail and expressways.

“When it comes to social justice, Narendra Modi has brought in many laws and provided legal protection to the backward people in the society through measures like setting up of National Commission for Backward Classes. He has made a difference in the lives of the poor by building houses and toilets. “, he noted.

Ilaiyaraaja has also appreciated PM Modi’s women-centric development initiatives like raising of marriage age for women, free LPG gas cylinders and schemes related to education of girl children.

He noted that Dr. Ambedkar would be proud to see the change brought about by the law against Triple Talaq and ‘Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao’ initiative.

“The book also points out where Dr. Ambedkar and Narendra Modi come together as personalities. Both experienced poverty and oppression and worked to eradicate it. Both were big dreamers about India who believe in action.”, Ilaiyaraaja notes.

Mr. Ilaiyaraaja has also appreciated the ‘Atmanirbhar Bharat’ initiative saying that the ‘self-reliant’ India that Prime Minister Modi is building will be a fitting tribute to India’s freedom fighters.

As a concluding note, Ilaiyaraaja recommends the book to youngsters to know about the two great sons of the soil and how a new India is being built according to the dreams of the freedom fighters.

However, this foreword written by Ilaiyaraaja for the book has irked the supporters of the ruling regime in Tamil Nadu and their allies.

Netizens who identify themselves as ‘Dravidian Stockists’, ‘Periyarists’ and ‘Ambedkarites’ have started trending a vile hashtag targetting the maestro.

A Twitter user named ‘Shafeeq’ says that equating PM Modi and Dr. Ambedkar amounts to ‘Sanghi’-ness.

Another handle which identified itself as ‘Dravidian Stock’ goes on to spew expletives against PM Modi and Ilaiyaraaja.

Another handle sympathetic to the ruling regime abuses Ilaiyaraaja for his comments praising PM Modi.

A Twitter user having Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin’s picture abuses Ilaiyaraaja with the vile hashtag.

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

Tamil Puthandu is on Chithirai 1 and not Thai 1 as claimed by ‘Dravidian Stockists’

Puthaandu or the Tamil New Year marks the first day of the first month (Chithirai) of the Hindu Tamil calendar that is based on the solar cycle. It usually falls on the 14th of April of the English Gregorian calendar.

Not just by Tamil Hindus, the commencement of the new year is celebrated as Vishu in Kerala, Rongali Bihu in Assam, Pohela Boisakh in Bengal, Bishuva Sankranti in Odisha, Jud Sheetal in parts of Bihar, etc. Even countries like Malaysia, Indonesia, Bali, Cambodia, Laos, Sri Lanka, Thailand, etc also celebrate the traditional New Year around this time.

However, the DMK and other ‘Dravidian Stockists’ observe Pongal (which occurs around January 14) as Tamil New Year as they argue that celebrating Chithirai 1 as the beginning of a new year amounts to following a ‘Brahmin-dominated’ or Sanskritic tradition which goes against Dravidian ideologies.

But no matter how much the ‘Dravidian Stockists’ try to distort and deride our culture which is based on science, there is also enough evidence in ancient Tamil literature that the first day of the Chithirai month marks the beginning of a new year.

“திண்ணிலை மருப்பின் ஆடு தலையாக விண்ணூர்பு திரிதரும் வீங்கு செலல் மண்டிலம்”

Thinnilai Marruppin Aadu Thalaiyaaga Vinnurpu Thiritharum Veengu Sella Mandilam

The above quote by Nakkeerar, a famous Tamil poet of the Sangam age, notes that the world runs with the goat (Mesha Rasi/Aries) as the first sign.

Not only in this Sangam song, many ancient Tamil songs that are about the astronomical predictions and changes in position of planets and starts.

Kudalur Kizhar is another poet of the Sangam era whose poems are part of the Kurunthogai (166, 167, 214) and Purananuru (229). In the poem in Purananuru, where he predicts the death of Chera ruler Yanaikatchei Mantharanj Cheral Irumborai (62-42 BC), he mentions Chithirai month and Mesha rasi.

In essence, the first month of the year is the month of Chithirai during spring when the Sun enters Mesha (Aries) zodiac sign. The year ends with the month of Panguni when the sun comes up in Pisces. This is the solar calendar that is followed across the country while there are many communities in different states that follows the lunar calendar.

Image
Source: India In Pixels

There is a reason why the harvest festival is celebrated in Thai (January) and the New Year in Chithirai (April). Earlier, after harvesting the crops in the Thai month (January-February) farmers take short period of rest in the months of Masi and Panguni (February-April) and start their farming again from Chithirai (April) which marks the beginning of the spring season.

So, the festivals that we celebrate are part of ancient knowledge and tradition handed over to us by our ancestors. They also signify the rich cultural heritage of this land.

Hence, Puthandu is not a day that can be changed to the whims and fancies of a bunch of politicians and their stooges to peddle their nonsensical agenda. No matter how hard the inimical forces might try to delink Hinduism with Tamil culture, they will fail. Miserably.

Back in 2008, when the ruling government in Tamil Nadu was DMK, the then Chief Minister, M Karunanidhi passed the Tamil Nadu New Year (Declaration) Bill 2008, changing the Tamil New Year from Chithirai 1 (April 14th) to Thai 1 (January 14th or 15th).

This ridiculous change was in action for three years until it was rescinded by the AIADMK in August 2011. The DMK’s move to delink Tamil and Hindu culture did not find any resonance with the Tamil people as Tamil people continue to celebrate New Year on Chithirai 1 rejecting the DMK’s move to the dustbin.

And it will remain there!

(With inputs from Sundar Raja Cholan‘s Facebook Post in Tamil)

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

“Make a commitment in Tamil New Year to save Mother Soil”: Sadhguru

“All Tamil people must make a commitment in this Tamil New Year to save our mother soil,” said Sadhguru, Founder-Isha Foundation.

In his congratulatory message on the occasion of the Tamil New Year, Sadhguru said: “My hearty Tamil New Year greetings to all the Tamil people. Our nation is about to complete 75 years of independence. We have made a lot of achievements during this period. But it is unfortunate that we do not take adequate measures to protect the soil. More than 60 per cent of our total population is engaged in agriculture. The fertility of our soil has been greatly reduced in the last 40 years. Thus, the farmers face a lot of vulnerabilities. Our diet is deficient in essential nutrients. Thus, people get many different diseases.”

Sadhguru is currently on a 100 days, 30,000 km journey across 27 nations to raise awareness and build political consensus for urgent policy initiatives to prevent soil extinction. Speaking more about his journey, he said, “This problem is not only in Tamil Nadu but all over the world. Therefore, to protect the soil, we have started the Save Soil Movement. I have been traveling on a motorcycle from London to Tamil Nadu to create awareness among the people about this. I have met and talked to many people in each country, including various department heads and scientists. We are working to enact legislation to ensure that soils contain at least 3 to 6 per cent organic matter.”

He further added, “Microbes that can live in the soil may be invisible to our eyes. But we cannot survive without those microbes. About 60 per cent of microbes live in our bodies, not just in the soil. Scientists say that if we do not take appropriate action now, there will be a great famine in the next 30 to 40 years. Therefore, we must act now to protect soil fertility.”

The Movement aims to reach 3.5 billion people globally or 60% of the world’s electorate, who can vote to Save Soil. Understanding the criticality to get the whole world concerned and talk about this issue, he urged, “All Tamil people should be fully involved in this. Children should write letters to the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu asking him to enact appropriate laws to protect soil fertility. Others need to write letters to your MLAs. In addition, everyone should talk more about soil conservation on social media.”

He signed off by saying, “In the Tamil New Year, everyone must commit to save the soil which is our mother. This is our basic duty and responsibility. Happy Tamil New Year once again to all the dear Tamil people.”

In an urgent bid to reverse and halt soil degradation, Sadhguru on 21st March 2022, embarked on a Save Soil movement journey and has passed through UK, Netherlands, Czech Republic, Austria, Slovenia, Italy, Switzerland, France and Belgium. He has been interacting with opinion makers, politicians, media persons, ecologists, influencers, general public during the journey garnering massive support for the movement.

(This is an official press release from Isha Foundation. The Commune was not involved in creating this content.)

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

TN govt school teacher in Kanyakumari abuses Hindus, forces students to convert to Christianity

A government school teacher in Tamil Nadu’s Kanyakumari district reportedly made objectionable remarks about Hindus and indulged in preaching Christianity to her students.

Beatrice Thangam works as a tailoring and sewing teacher at the Government Higher Secondary school located in Kannattuvilai of Kanyakumari district.

In a video, a student studying class 6 in the school can be heard accusing her teacher Beatrice Thangam of derogating Hindus as ‘sathaan‘ (devil) and glorifying Christianity.

“She asks us to read Bible. We told her that we are Hindus and we read only Bhagavad Gita. She told that Bhagavat Gita is bad and asked us to read Bible as it had good philosophy.”, the student narrates in the video.

The girl student also says in the video that the teacher told stories about a Christian and a ‘saathaan’, referring to Hindus as devils.

She also says that the teacher makes students to stitch the Christian Cross and forces them to kneel down and recite Christian prayers.

When asked if only she was subject to such forced conversion, the student says that the teacher does it with all Hindu students.

After the incident came to light, the initial inquiry was done by the District Education Officer (DEO) and the School Education Department has now suspended the teacher.

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

 

Idols found vandalized at temple near Kanchipuram

Idols of Hindus Gods at the Selva Vinayagaram Temple near Kanchipuram were reportedly vandalized by unknown miscreants on the night of April 10, 2022.

The Selva Vinayagar Temple is located in Ammayappanallur village near Uthiramerur in Kanchipuram district. The temple is managed by maintainend by the people of the village.

The temple has idols of Lord Ayyappan, Lord Sivan, Nandi, Goddess Parvati and the Navagrahams.

Regular poojas are conducted twice a day – morning and evening. As usual, poojas were held on the night of April 10 and the temple was closed at 8 PM.

The temple priest who opened the temple the next day morning found many of the idols vandalized. The head and right arm of the idol of Lord Ayyappan were found broken and lying on the ground.. The Navagraha idols were also broken.

The Hindu Munnani in Kanchipuram district has filed a police complaint seeking appropriate action against the culprits. Police are on the look out for the unidentified miscreants who broke the idols.

(With inputs from Dinamalar)

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

The Ayodhya Mandapam Controversy Explained

On Monday (April 11, 2022), the Hindu Religious & Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department of the Tamil Nadu Government, took over the decades old Ayodhya Mandapam in Chennai, despite strong protests from local residents and other Hindu orgnizations.

Officers of the HR&CE department led by Executive Officer Shakthi and Assistant Commissioner Kavithini, arrived on the spot and took possession of the Mandapam while those who protested were forcibly removed and detained by the police.

The Tamil Nadu government’s move to take over the Ayodhya Mandapam came just a day after the auspicious occassion of Ram Navami.

About Ayodhya Mandapam

The Ayodhya Aswamedha Maha Mandapam located on Arya Gowda Road in West Mambalam locality of Chennai, is a community hall where Hindu spiritual discourses and poojas are held periodically.

The Mandapam is run by Sri Ram Samaj, a registered society, managed by an elected body comprising of a President, Vice President, Secretary, Assistant Secretary and a Treasurer.

It was registered in the year 1958 and the name “Sri Ram Samaj” was given by Brahmasri Somadeva Sarma, the father of famous spiritual discourser, Srivatsa Jayarama Sarma.

The Ayodhya Mandapam is the brainchaild by one K. Subramania Iyer, fondly remembered as KS who along with Srinivasa Rao, a reporter of The Hindu, thought of celebrating Sri Rama Navami with great fervour and public participation.

Subramania Iyer along with Srinivasa Rao approached noted Congress leader Veppathur Venkatrama Iyer who gave a donation of ₹25 to celebrate Ram Navami that year. He also helped them collect funds from the neighbourhood and amount of ₹242 was collected with which the first Rama Navami celebrations were held under a thatched shed on a vacant land in Bhaktavatsalam Street, opposite to the present Ayodhya Mandapam.

Later a four ground plot was identified in Arya Gowda Road. Congress leader Venkatrama Iyer helped solve the encumbrance and other legalities the land held. The cost of the land was ₹5400 which was made available by K. Sundaresa Iyer the younger brother of K. Subramania as a loan which was repaid over three years.

The Ayodhya Mandapam is not a temple. It does not have a vigraham (deity idol) that has been as per the Agama traditions. A Thanjavur painting of Lord Ram purchased in 1957 is worshipped by devotees.

Other Properties Of Sri Ram Samaj

Years later, a vacant plot was purchased in Murthy Street and a community centre was built which today exists as the Mithilapuri Kalyana Mandapam.

It is primarily used by poor and middle class Brahmins to hold domestic functions like weddings, seemandham (baby shower), ayushyahomam (1st birthday), sashtiabdapoorthi (60th anniversary) and sadabhsishekam (80th anniversary).

Another plot was purchased to establish “Gnanavapi” in 1983, which is used for performing obsequies to departed souls.

The Sri Ram Samaj also establihed the Sri Sitaram Vidyalaya Matriculation Higher Secondary School in 1987.

How An Internal Dispute Let The State Enter Ayodhya Mandapam

In 2013, a person who was rejected a membership in Sri Ram Samaj, shot off a letter to the HR&CE department alleging mismanagement of funds by the Samaj.

Subsequently, the HR&CE department took over the Ayodhya Mandapam in January 2014 through an order dated December 31, 2013, citing Section 49 (1) of the HR&CE Act.

This move by the HR&CE Department came on the same day the Supreme Court ruled against the Tamil Nadu government’s control over the Chidambaram Natarajar Temple.

A ‘Fit Person’ was appointed by the HR&CE Department back then to probe the finances and manage the affairs of the Mandapam.

So, technically, the take over of Ayodhya Mandapam by HR&CE did not happen now but in 2014 itself when the AIADMK was in power.

Just like now, the government’s move to take over the Mandapam was resisted by locals. Sri Ram Samaj filed a petition in the Madras High Court against the take over.

The petitioner claimed that the Ayodhya Mandapam was not a temple as no idol was installed as per the Agama Shastra for public worship. Sri Ram Samaj contended that only portraits of Lord Ram, Goddess Sita and Lord Hanuman were present for which poojas were performed.

However on March 31, 2022, the Madras High Court dismissing the writ petition, passed orders that whether the Ayodhya Mandapam is a temple or not cannot be decided in writ proceedings.

Justice VM Velumani who passed the orders noted that it was open to the petitioner to challenge the proceedings of the HR&CE before an appropriate forum.

As the Court did not give an injunction, it became easy for the ruling DMK government to swing into action.

The matter in effect is sub-judice as the Court has neither allowed the HR&CE to proceed with the take over nor has stopped it.

This is how an internal dispute in the Samaj has led to the ‘secular’ state to brazenly enter a ‘religious’ place.

Why HR&CE’s Move Is Illegal

As mentioned earlier, the Ayodhya Mandapam is not a temple built according to Agama Shastras but a community hall used for religious purpose. There is no deity installed as per the Agama Shastra and poojas are performed to the portraits/figurines of Lord Ram, Lord Sita, and Lord Hanuman.

So, the HR&CE prima facie has no locus standi to interfere in the affairs of the Mandapam.

However, the HR&CE has contended that it found idols during the inspection adding that it is a public temple and that the Samaj had been receiving huge amount of money through hundial.

Also, the HR&CE Department had appointed the Executive Officer (EO) of the Baladandayudhapani Temple in Teynampet as the ‘fit person’ to manage the affairs of the Mandapam. T.R. Ramesh of the Temple Worshippers Society has said that the appointment of the EO is invalid as he had no appointment order in the first place.

He also said that a government servant could not be appointed as trustee in the place of sole trustee, and that only a practising Hindu can be.

The Supreme Court’s judgement in the Chidambaram Natarajar Temple Case implies that the government cannot take over a temple without substantial proven mismanagement.

However, HR&CE officials have only taken action based on ‘allegations’ that money was being misused by members for personal use.

Even if the take over has been effected, the government cannot be in control of a Hindu religious institution for eternity. The apex court in the Chidambaram Natarajar Temple case had observed, “Even if the management of a temple is taken over to remedy the evil, the management must be handed over to the person concerned immediately after the evil stands remedied. Continuation thereafter would tantamount to usurpation of their proprietary rights or violation of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution in favour of the persons deprived. Therefore, taking over of the management in such circumstances must be for a limited period… Supercession of rights of administration cannot be of a permanent enduring nature.”

The Double Standards

Many Hindu devotees and social media activists have questioned what was the urgency for the HR&CE department to take over the Ayodhya Mandapam.

Back in October 2021, the Madras High Court had directed the HR&CE Department to evict the Queensland amusement park from 21 acres of land in Poonamallee belonging to Kasi Viswanathaswami temple and Venugopalaswami temple.

The amusement park owner late ‘Oorvasi’ Selvaraj who also founded the King’s Engineering College, was a former Congress MLA and his wife Nalini Selvaraj is today a prominent Christian evangelist.

Despite the Court’s order, no action has been taken to evict the encroachers from the temple land.

The haste in which the HR&CE has acted to take over the Ayodhya Mandapam while turning a blind eye to the encroachment of Queensland has raised questions about the intention of the ruling DMK.

An Act Of Vengeance?

The West Mambalam area in Chennai is predominantly inhabited by members of the Brahmin community. The DMK’s visceral hatred and targetting of the community is well known.

In the recently concluded urban local body elections, voters of West Mambalam had elected BJP leader Uma Anandan as the ward councillor.

She is the lone BJP councillor in the 200-member Greater Chennai Corporation where a majority of the councillors are from the DMK.

That a Brahmin woman BJP leader has managed to win a seat in Chennai, which is considered to be a stronghold of the DMK is a political angle that is gaining traction.

 

On April 1, 2022, Tamil Nadu Governor R.N. Ravi visited the Ayodhya Mandapam to inaugurate the Ram Navami celebrations.

It is apparent that the ruling DMK does not share a cordial relationship with Governor Ravi as they have been at loggerheads ever since he assumed office.

The fact that the Tamil Nadu government’s move came just days after his visit lends much credit to the allegations of political vendetta behind the move.

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.

MEA Jaishankar royally shuts up American journalist over question about India’s purchase of Russian oil

In a hard-hitting and suave response to a question posed by an American journalist, Indian Minister of External Affairs said that India’s total purchase of oil from Russia in a month is probably less than what Europe does in an afternoon.

India’s Minister of External Affairs S. Jaishankar and Defence Minister Rajnath Singh are currently in the USA to participate in the fourth India-USA 2+2 Ministerial Dialogue.

US President Joe Biden also held a virtual meeting with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi where the two discussed the Russia-Ukraine situation.

External Affairs Minister Jaishankar and Defence Minister Rajnath Singh addressed a press after the 2+2 meeting with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and US Secretary of Defence Lloyd Austin.

An American journalist posed a question to the US Secretary of State Antony Blinken saying that there reports of Delhi and Moscow engaging in a currency exchange mechanism for future oil purchases.

“Did you tell Secretary [Minister] Jaishankar that these could risk violation of not just current sanctions but also risks violating CAATSA?”, the lady journalist asked.

After Blinken’s response, Minister Jaishankar said that India has made a number of statements on the Russia-Ukraine war in the United Nations, the Indian Parliament, and in other forums.

“And briefly, what those positions state is that we are against the conflict. We are for dialogue and diplomacy. We are for urgent cessation of violence, and we are prepared to contribute in whatever way to these objectives,” he said.

“If you’re looking at (India’s) energy purchases from Russia, I’d suggest your attention should be on Europe. We buy some energy necessary for our energy security. But I suspect, looking at figures, our purchases for the month would be less than what Europe does in an afternoon,” Jaishankar said.

The White House too came in India’s defence on the issue of oil purchase noting that its total purchase is less than one and two per cent as against 10 per cent from the United States.

Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.