Home News National Thirupparankundram Deepam Case: ‘What Harm Can A Lamp Cause If Lit For...

Thirupparankundram Deepam Case: ‘What Harm Can A Lamp Cause If Lit For Two Hours, Once A Year?’, Asks Petitioner

TN Government’s Own 1981 Archaeology Book Identified Deepathoon As A Lamp-Lighting Site, Yet HR&CE Dept Prevents Hindus From Lighting Karthigai Deepam At Deepathoon

Hindu worshippers opposing the Tamil Nadu government’s contention that the Deepathoon (lamp pillar) atop Thirupparankundram hill in Madurai district is merely a survey pillar with no religious significance, on Thursday (19 November 2026), urged the Supreme Court to allow the traditional Karthigai Deepam to be lit on the structure, as reported in Indian Express.

Senior Advocate P. Valliappan, appearing for Rama Ravikumar, the original petitioner before the Madras High Court, argued that the pillar’s physical features clearly indicated its purpose as a lamp stand and that lighting the Deepam for approximately two hours once a year would cause harm to no one.

Pointing to an image of the structure, Valliappan challenged the claim that it was a survey pillar, stating, “They say it’s a survey pillar. Please look carefully — this is the top of the so-called stone pillar. Normally the survey stones will not have a hole. There is a depression here. That is for keeping a copper cauldron or a small silver bucket or iron bucket, putting ghee and cotton wick and then lighting a lamp which will be there for about 2 hours on Maha Karthigai Deepam.”

Questioning the opposition to the ritual, he further asked, “I ask myself this question, how is anyone affected by just lighting this lamp for two hours, one day a year? I am yet to get an answer.”

The Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi is hearing appeals challenging the Madras High Court’s orders permitting the lighting of the Deepam on the Deepathoon.

On 1 December 2025, a single-judge bench of the Madras High Court allowed Ravikumar’s writ petition and directed the temple administration to light the Karthigai Deepam on the pillar, holding that the structure stood on temple-owned land. The Division Bench subsequently upheld the order. The HR&CE Commissioner has now challenged the High Court’s decision before the Supreme Court.

Petitioners Cite 1923 Civil Court Judgment And 1931 Privy Council Ruling On Temple Ownership

Speaking to the press after Thursday’s hearing, Valliappan said the petitioners had supported the judgments of both the single-judge bench and the Division Bench of the Madras High Court.

He said the Deepathoon was situated within the temple’s property and that its ownership had already been established through earlier judicial proceedings.

He said, “Since the matter is pending before the court, we are not supposed to say too many things about what has happened inside. We supported the judgements of the learned single judge and the Division bench and stated that no harm will be cause to anyone by lighting a Deepam. They just use a copper cauldron, ghee and cotton wicks. So therefore, by lighting this deepam once a year for about 2 hours on the second summit of the hill won’t harm any community or any religion. So, there is no reason to prevent the lighting of the same; especially when the pillar, the Deepathoon lies within the precincts of the temple property as declared by the 1920 suit judgement passed by the civil court in 1923 and confirmed by the Privy Council in 1931. So that was basically our submission.”

The petitioners also opposed the interim stay sought by the HR&CE Commissioner, arguing that there was no justification for preventing the temple from conducting its traditional Deepam ritual on its own property.

Petitioners Hope Deepam Will Be Lit On November 24

Valliappan said the immediate objective was to ensure that the Karthigai Deepam was lit on Thirupparankundram hill on 24 November 2026.

He pointed out that despite the Madras High Court’s 1 December 2025 order, the Tamil Nadu government had refused to permit the lighting of the Deepam last year, even though Karthigai Deepam fell on December 3.

He also clarified that the present appeal was filed by the current TVK government and not the previous government, countering what he described as public confusion over which regime was opposing the ritual.

He said, “The other side is praying for an interim order, we are opposing. Therefore, our intention is that atleast this year the Karthigai Deepam which falls on 24th of November, the Thirupparankundram Hill should have this Deepam lit up on this day. Last year, the single judge had passed the order on 1st of December. And the Karthigai Deepam was on 3rd of December. Unfortunately, the state refused to permit the lighting of Deepam and the present regime has filed the present SLP. It was not the previous government. There was a change in government in May and this SLP by the Commissioner was filed in the month of June. There is some confusion amongst the public whether it was the previous regime or the present regime. The present regime is also equally opposing the lighting of the Deepam in a land which admittedly belongs to the Devasthanam.”

The matter has been adjourned to Friday, November 20, for continuation of arguments on behalf of the petitioners. Senior Advocates Guru Krishna Kumar and S. Sriram are expected to present further submissions supporting the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam on the temple-owned Deepathoon.

The Supreme Court is presently considering the interim relief sought in the matter, with the judges indicating that detailed arguments on the merits of the case could be taken up during the final hearing.

Subscribe to our channels on WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram and YouTube to get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.