
Dravidianist Dr J Amalorpavanathan who was a former member of the Tamil Nadu State Planning Commission and retired vascular surgeon, has come under fire after making contradictory claims about his acquaintance with journalist Siddharth Prabhakar, prompting the latter to publicly challenge his statements.
The controversy began after Siddharth questioned how journalists identify Amalorpavanathan when quoting him as an expert. Sharing a newspaper clipping that described him as a former member of the State Planning Commission and a retired vascular surgeon, Siddharth argued that readers should also be informed of his political campaigning for the DMK in the 2026 Assembly elections.
“I strongly feel journalists should identify @AmalJos95950131 as an expert who campaigned for the DMK in the 2026 assembly elections. Apart from other professional posts he headed. It is only fair that your readers know who the expert being quoted is,” Siddharth wrote.

Amalorpavanathan responded by defending his decision to campaign for Dr Ezhilan, describing him as his former student.
“I campaigned for my student Dr. Ezhilan because I know him to be a caring and competent doctor. If have cared to see the videoreleased then, you will know that I have said clearly that I don’t belong to the party but campaigned because of my affection towards my student,” he wrote.

The exchange took another turn when another Dravidianist told Amalorpavanathan not to justify himself to what he called paid TVK trolls, referring specifically to Siddharth. Responding to this, Amalorpavanathan claimed: “I don’t even know that person.”

Siddharth immediately challenged that claim, pointing to their previous interactions. He posted a screenshot of a WhatsApp conversation with Amalorpavanathan dated September 21, 2020, discussing Swedish author Stieg Larsson’s Millennium Trilogy.
In the exchange, Amalorpavanathan had shared a passage attributed to Larsson about journalism and reporting. When Siddharth asked whether he had read the trilogy, Amalorpavanathan replied that he was reading it for the second time. Siddharth mentioned two additional books connected to the trilogy, prompting Amalorpavanathan to respond: “Then you are my senior.”
Siddharth described Amalorpavanathan’s denial as disappointing, accusing him of disowning their seven-year acquaintance to please what he called a “DMK IT wing 2.0 troll”.

Amalorpavanathan then attempted to explain away the exchange by claiming that it had been seven years since he had communicated with Siddharth.
“It is 7 years since I had any communication with you. You must understand that at my age it is almost impossible to remember a person who communicates after a 7yr gap. It has nothing to do with DMK. BTW Steig Larson Trilogy is still my favorite,” he wrote.
Siddharth, however, pointed out that their interaction was not limited to the 2020 WhatsApp exchange. He reminded Amalorpavanathan that the latter had invited him to his residence in 2023, and offered to publish a screenshot of that conversation as well.
“Another lie @AmalJos95950131 sir. You invited me to your residence in 2023. Do you want me to share a screenshot of that conversation?” Siddharth posted.

Dravidianist Amalorpavanathan’s attempt to distance himself from Siddharth has only made the controversy worse. He can defend campaigning for Ezhilan as an act of affection for a former student. But pretending not to know a journalist with whom he had exchanged messages — and who says he was invited to his residence in 2023 — is an entirely different matter. In trying to appease DMK supporters attacking Siddharth, Amalorpavanathan has ended up having to explain his own words and actions.
Subscribe to our channels on WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram and YouTube to get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.



