“Do You Think I Am A Beggar?” Pastor Gets Angry On Church Members For Donating Just 3 Oranges
An undated rant by a Catholic priest directed at Christian Church worshippers and throwing of offerings given to him has gone viral on social media.
Father Joseph Christian, is a Parish Priest of St. Anne’s Church in Rajakrishnapuram, Tirunelveli District, which is under the Tuticorin Diocese.
According to reports, 30 families from the Susaiappar Anbiam group gave only three oranges as an offering to Father Joseph Christian during the prayer ceremony on the day of the incident.
Enraged by the offerings, Father Joseph Christian can be seen in the video humiliating the 30 families of the Soosiappar Anbiam for having only offered 3 oranges to him. He is seen throwing the offerings and berating them for not being generous enough.
In the video, Father Joseph Christian can be heard saying, “Dear all, Soosaiyappar Anbiam has arranged for this beautiful prayer meet. All of you have come together and arranged this. I applaud your efforts. But I have to give you one advise. We have spent thousands of rupees to arrange this. But what is the use of all these. Rain spoiled it last time. What is the use of having you?”
He added, “First of all, all thirty families in the assembly should participate and give their offerings. Do you think I am a beggar? You have given me 3 oranges. What should I do with these. I can only throw in three directions (actually throwing the oranges). If you are a millionaire, so I am. Do not forget. If you are a billionaire, so I am. Till I leave this Parish, don’t you dare forget this. Do you think I am a beggar by donating only 3 oranges? Never in your life you should forget this.”
The Roman Catholic across the world is divided geographically into dioceses, each of which are ministered to by a Bishop. A Diocese has more than 100 parishes on average, each of which would have 10,000-20,000 flock, ministered to by a Parish Priest. Further, units of 20-50 families are organised as an ANPIAM (Animating New Pastoral Integral Approach Mission) known colloquially in Tamil as an Anbiam. The Anbiam is the smallest unit of the Catholic church in Tamil Nadu. Specific services are to be managed by an ANBIAM, to be managed by the families in this group. It also appears that these families are expected to contribute to the running of the Church financially also.
The Tuticorin Diocese is no stranger to controversy. In a video that went viral earlier, a priest who resembles Fr. Silvester Fernando M., Parish Priest of St.Charles’ Church, Subbiahpuram, Thoothukudi is seemingly so heavily under the influence of intoxicants that he is unable to officiate at a wedding.
https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=603562804223527
Earlier, the Bishop of Tuticorin Diocese, Rt Rev Yvon Ambroise, now Bishop Emeritus of Tuticorin Diocese, was charged with aiding politically inspired protests at Koodankulam, using money remitted by organizations overseas.
Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.












Hypocrisy Much? Rahman Shares Humanity-Over-Religion ‘Kerala Story’, Here’s How He Put His Religion Above Humanity
Ahead of the release of ‘The Kerala Story’, a film depicting the menace of love jihad, Oscar-winning music composer AR Rahman took to virtue-signalling sharing an old clip of a Hindu couple marrying at a mosque in Kerala.
The video which Rahman shared was three years old and is a coverage of The News Minute of a Hindu couple named Anju and Sharath marrying at the Cheruvally Muslim Jamaath mosque in Alappuzha.
This old video was shared on Twitter by the handle Comrade From Kerala (@ComradeMallu) whose bio reads as “Communist from Kerala… Sanghis, Sudappis and all religious terrorists please keep away.”
Quote-tweeting the video of Comrade From Kerala, AR Rahman said that love for humanity has to be unconditional.
But here are a few instances when Rahman put his religion above his work and humanity.
Incident 1
Piraisoodan is a famous award-winning Tamil poet who has penned lyrics for many Tamil songs. He had worked with Rahman during his initial days when the latter was scoring ad jingles. Piraisoodan has also penned lyrics for some of the songs of Rahman.
In an interview to a Tamil YouTube channel, Piraisoodan said that once when he had gone to Rahman’s home, he was asked to remove the Vibhuti (sacred ash) and Kumkum (vermilion) by Rahman’s mother. Rahman along with family had already converted to Islam by then.
However, Piraisoodan, did not oblige and refused to remove the Hindu religious marks on his forehead saying that he has been having them since childhood.
Incident 2
It is hard for a Rahman fan to not have listened to the song ‘Kalayil Dhinamum‘ from the film New.
The song is an ode to mothers penned by the late lyricist Vaali who is known for being candid.
In an incident recorded by Vaali, he said that the inital lyrics of the song which adulated mother to the status of God had to be changed because of Rahman.
The initial lines that was penned by Vaali was:
Kalai Dhinamum Kan Vizhithaal (Every morning when I wake up)
Naan Kai Thodum Deivam Amma (The God I fold my hands to pray, is mother)
The shooting for the song had already been completed.
However, Rahman objected to these lines saying that Islam does not allow him to equate mother with his God and asked lyricist Vaali to change the lyric.
“Vaali sir, in my religion we’re not supposed to equate mother with God. Please replace the word with some other word.”, Rahman apparently told Vaali over phone.
An irritated Vaali later changed the word ‘Deivam‘ which means God in Tamil to ‘Devathai‘, the Tamil word for angel, on Rahman’s insistance.
Incident 3
Sources in the Tamil music industry also note that AR Rahman did not compose the Ayyappa Song that comes in the film Boys (2003).
Even the casette/CD cover of the music album does not mention the Ayyappa Song.
It is said that the Ayyappa song from the movie was composed by his music programmer Pravin Mani.
While it is speculated that Rahman chose to not compose the Ayyappa song as it would be in contradiction to his Islamic beliefs, what is worth mentioning is that the same Rahman had composed the enchanting ‘Anbendra Mazhayile‘ a song venerating Jesus from the film Minsara Kanavu (1997).
In all these above instances, Rahman put his religion above anything else. Where did humanity-over-religion go then?
Rahman has always been viewed as an Indian and his religion has never bothered his fans who span across faiths.
But is Rahman a man blinded by his faith?
Click here to subscribe to The Commune on Telegram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.