
The TVK government on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, urged the Supreme Court to stay the Madras High Court’s order permitting the lighting of the traditional Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoon near the Sikandar Badusha Dargah atop Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai, arguing that the structure was a survey pillar and not a religious Deepathoon, as reported in LiveLaw.
Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the Madurai District Collector, told a bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi that the pillar had been erected for an entirely different purpose and was not a stone pillar traditionally meant for lighting the temple lamp.
“Our fear as a State is that if the judgment remains undisturbed, all these pillars will find religious colours and people will start doing these things,” he submitted.
“Let the Court’s jurisdiction not be expanded, otherwise thousands of survey pillars in country will start becoming religious,” he asserted.
The State’s plea seeks a stay of the Madras High Court Division Bench judgment of January 2026, which upheld a December 2025 Single Judge order directing the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy Temple administration to light the Karthigai Deepam at the disputed stone pillar, reportedly located about 50 metres from the Sikandar Badusha Dargah according to the Single Judge’s order.
The High Court had rejected the State’s apprehensions of a public-order disturbance, describing them as an “imaginary ghost”, and held that the pillar was situated on temple land.
State Argues Lamp-Lighting Tradition is Confined to Uchi Pillaiyar Temple
Sankaranarayanan referred the bench to photographs and a drone image of Thiruparankundram hill, pointing to the Subramaniaswamy Temple at the foothill and the Dargah on the other side.
He argued that the traditional place for lighting the Karthigai Deepam was the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple, also referred to as the Deepa Mandapam site, and that attempts to light the lamp at other locations had previously been rejected on at least three occasions.
The State maintained that permitting the lamp to be lit at another location would disrupt the established religious practice. It also argued that courts should not intervene in matters concerning religious customs in the manner sought by the petitioners.
The lawyer further claimed that priests had stated that the lamp was traditionally lit only at the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple, “to their knowledge”, and that this was in accordance with Agama practices.
According to arguments advanced by the State, the government had been unable to identify the nature of the disputed pillar during the earlier proceedings before the Division Bench. It is now contending that the structure is a trigonometrical survey pillar and not a Deepathoon.
The State also relied on images presented before the Supreme Court, arguing that the material available now was not placed before the Single Judge or the Division Bench during the earlier proceedings.
Sankaranarayanan repeatedly referred to the disputed structure as a survey pillar rather than a Deepathoon and argued that there was no necessity to light the lamp at what he termed the “second pillar”.
He maintained that the decision on where the lamp should be lit ought to be left to the temple priests and that the traditional practice had always been confined to the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple. He also questioned the jurisdiction of the writ court to intervene in the matter of religious practice.
The arguments reportedly took up considerable time, with the bench indicating that only around 30 minutes remained for the parties to complete their submissions.
Dargah Seeks Stay, Disputes Ownership of Disputed Pillar
Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi, appearing for the Sikandar Badusha Dargah, also sought a stay of the High Court’s Division Bench order, arguing that the Dargah had not been given adequate opportunity to present its case during the earlier proceedings.
Ahmadi submitted that the Single Judge had passed the order without granting sufficient time to the Dargah to file its response as required under the High Court Rules. He also objected to the Single Judge’s site inspection, arguing that it had been conducted without prior notice to the Dargah.
“Before the single judge, I was not impleaded. Then he impleads me suo moto, then he goes on inspection of the same day. Ordinarily a Justice sitting in a constitutional court does not go on inspection. He then delivered the judgement and we did not have enough time.”
Ahmadi further argued that the disputed pillar was situated in an area between Nellithope and the Dargah and that the Single Judge would not have concluded that the structure fell within temple property had the Dargah been given notice before the inspection.
He also pointed out that the Division Bench had, to an extent, acknowledged the Dargah’s contention that it had not been given adequate opportunity before the Single Judge, but had held that the defect was cured since the Dargah was subsequently heard during the appeal.
Ahmadi referred to earlier judgments rejecting attempts to light the lamp at a new location and argued that any attempt to establish a new religious custom should be pursued through a civil suit rather than a Public Interest Litigation.
The Dargah’s counsel also disputed the ownership of the disputed area, contending that the pillar was located approximately 20 metres from the Dargah’s region and fell within property belonging to the Dargah. The distance from the Dargah was also disputed during the proceedings, with references to the Single Judge’s order indicating around 50 metres and the Division Bench reportedly referring to a distance of approximately 200 metres.
The arguments also saw the State and the Dargah contesting the nature and ownership of the disputed location, with the State relying on its contention that the pillar was a survey structure, while the Dargah disputed the claim that the area belonged to the temple.
The hearing concluded for the day, with arguments scheduled to continue on Thursday.
Subscribe to our channels on WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram and YouTube to get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.



