Following the allegations levelled by Tamil Nadu Bharatiya Janata Party Chief K Annamalai, the “Mission Director” of the Fact-Checking Unit (FCU) set up by the Tamil Nadu government, Iyan Karthikeyan stepped into the scene.
To prove his worthiness, he “fact-checked” the claim made by Annamalai, or so we thought. Instead of proving that the milk contained a specific amount of fat as claimed or other details that pertained to the topic of discussion, he ended up fact-checking the “container” in which the sample was received.
He wrote, “Sample received in PET container But, Aavin is not selling milk in PET container and it is not mentioned as Aavin. Sample must be sent with original pack without any mal practice.”
Sample received in PET container But, Aavin is not selling milk in PET container and it is not mentioned as Aavin .
Sample must be sent with original pack without any mal practice. #FactCheck https://t.co/KWtnYsNz83 pic.twitter.com/4fhXf9u4rj
— Iyan Karthikeyan (@Iyankarthikeyan) November 20, 2023
Annamalai had posted about the difference in fat percentage in the Green Magic milk variant supplied by Aavin compared to what was claimed by them. He wrote on his X handle, “Tamil Nadu Government’s Aavin Milk Company has decided to stop the sale of green packet milk, which has been in use for the last forty years, is strongly condemned. The decision to stop the sale of green packet milk with 4.5% fat content and to sell purple packet milk with 3.5% fat content is an act of cheating the public. Orange packet milk, which should already contain 6% fat content, has 4.79% fat content, according to a study conducted by a Food Safety and Standardization Authority (FSSAI) approved laboratory. We have attached this test report for the Minister’s consideration. This corrupt DMK government is deliberately playing with the development of children who depend on Aavin company’s milk by reducing the fat content. Also, I urge the Tamil Nadu government to immediately stop deceiving the public by reducing the fat content of milk and not reducing the price, and provide quality milk at the price paid by the public.”
தமிழக அரசின் ஆவின் பால் நிறுவனம், கடந்த நாற்பது ஆண்டுகளாகப் பயன்பாட்டில் இருக்கும் பச்சை நிற பாக்கெட் பால் விற்பனையை நிறுத்திக் கொள்ள முடிவெடுத்திருப்பது வன்மையாகக் கண்டிக்கத்தக்கது.
மொத்தமாக சென்னையில், சுமார் 14.75 லட்சம் லிட்டர் விற்பனையாகும் ஆவின் பாலில், 40% பங்குள்ள, 4.5%… pic.twitter.com/6fLzNIISCk
— K.Annamalai (@annamalai_k) November 20, 2023
Iyan Karthikeyan’s dubious fact-check was debunked by netizens. One of them shared a video of how a test is done in the lab. The video showed how a sample is taken in a sterile PET container and how the process is carried out in a laboratory.
தோழர் @Iyankarthikeyan மக்கள் பணத்திலிருந்து 3L சம்பளமாக கொடுத்தலும், கொழுப்பு அளவிடும் முறை பால் பாக்கெட்லிருந்து நேரடியாக எடுப்பார்கள் என்று நினைத்திருந்த காரணத்தினால் நம் வரி பணத்தை சம்பாளமாக கொடுத்து போக அளவிடும் முறையும் சொல்லி கொடுப்போம் நாம் 🖤❤️#கொழுப்புதிருடன்_மனோ https://t.co/pEoOlfWpNt pic.twitter.com/AC5xGf7vij
— Bagavath Pratheep (@Bagavathprathee) November 20, 2023
Another netizen called out his assumption that samples taken for testing are taken directly from the milk packet rather than a sterile container. He also shared a detailed infographic on what a milk sample bottle looks like, what is it used for, etc.
லூசு பயலே Milk Sampling எடுப்பது pet bottleல தான் எடுப்பாங்க.. உனக்குலாம் எவன்டா 3 லட்சம் சம்பளம் பேசுனது.. ??
பால் பாக்கெட்டை நேரா போட்டா Test பண்ணுவானுக.. 😂😂😂 https://t.co/J4Pd95LEqV pic.twitter.com/5SamgBUTqF— Umapathy Shiva (@umapathyshiva) November 20, 2023
Tamil Nadu BJP Industrial Cell Vice President Selva Kumar slammed Iyan Karthikeyan claiming it to be dubious. He wrote, “FCU Karthikeyan & his team are getting paid crores & crores of taxpayers money only to give “murattu muttu” for all failures & misadventures of this govt. After 20 days of getting appointed as mission director, he just came out today with one single tweet asking for “original pack”. How can an illegal FCU dictate terms on how a sample should be tested? Do you mean to say that when blood samples are given, it should be taken from the body directly not just a few ml of sample blood? Cheating people is not new for this govt, In Feb 2023, Aavin Coimbatore started supplying green magic milk with just 3.5% milk printed on the back but on the front, it continued to say 4.5% in large font. When many milk dealers across TN started questioning the government, they introduced a new category Purple.”
FCU Karthikeyan & his team is getting paid crores & crores of taxpayers money only to give “murattu muttu” for all failures & mis-adventures of this govt. After 20 days of getting appointed as mission director, he just came out today with one single tweet asking for “original… https://t.co/SKKplMMhgt
— Selva Kumar (@Selvakumar_IN) November 20, 2023
Several others schooled the “Mission Director” of the FCU on how a sample is taken and in what container a milk sample is taken for testing.
This is how the milk sample is taken from the farmer for testing and based on the per liter price will be paid to the farmer. You should stick to your usual fake propaganda if you don't know this process. https://t.co/j3WZqO1dWB pic.twitter.com/dwZXayi1lz
— Murali (@MuraliS27) November 20, 2023
The hilarity here!
Fact-checking level: A+ science fiction.
Seems our man has never heard of 'sterilised standard containers' mentioned by the tech in the report which magically make it – 'not Avin.' https://t.co/x7Gal4vCAn
— Indu Makkal Katchi (Offl) 🇮🇳 (@Indumakalktchi) November 20, 2023
You say “sample”. Samples need not be in original container. They have taken a small quantity in a PET container and tested it. https://t.co/RjoZaexeIK
— Easy Normal Hard 🕉 🇮🇳 (@Symbianian) November 21, 2023
I don’t think it as a #FactCheck . You should have tested the milk and posted the results the so called original results. You are doing the job of a DMK IT wing. #200Rs https://t.co/AdZez6xFTc
— Naveen prabu (@naveen_prabu_) November 20, 2023
Subscribe to our channels on Telegram, WhatsApp, and Instagram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.