National News

Atul’s Suicide Is A Stark Warning To Kick And Wake Up The System

December 11, 2024
The Commune

The suicide of Atul Subhash, a Bengaluru-based engineer, has ignited widespread outrage across India, bringing attention to the issue of men’s rights and alleged systemic biases in the legal system. Atul’s tragic death has prompted his family to demand justice, highlighting the challenges faced by men in the face of false allegations and what they perceive as laws that favor women.

Atul, originally from Uttar Pradesh, was found hanging in his Bengaluru residence, leaving behind a 24-page suicide note and a 90-minute video. In the video, he claimed his estranged wife falsely accused him of various charges and harassed him with multiple court cases. Atul’s message detailed the immense frustration he felt, expressing that his efforts to fight back were futile. He blamed the system for his distress and called for justice before his death.

In the video, Atul said, “My name is Atul Subash. I am 34 years old and live in Bangalore. Today, I am contemplating suicide because I believe it is best for me to end my life. The money I earn only seems to empower my enemies and this vicious cycle will continue to escalate. The whole tax system harms both me and others, so it is best to end the supply value. In any case, they gave me suggestion to commit suicide. I believe this is the right solution, so I ask that no one come near my dead body after I am gone. Furthermore, I do not want to be resurrected until my harassers are punished. Without justice, there can be no true resurrection. Even if all the evidence is presented and everything is brought to light, if the court fails to punish the judge and other harassers, justice will not be served. Therefore, my ashes should be disposed of in a gutter so that I can understand the true value of life in this country. This is something I must do. I will speak with my parents separately. Please forgive me father and mother for burdening you all with my sorrows at this age. To those who are watching, may God bless you all.”

The Family’s Grief And Allegations

Atul’s father, Pawan Kumar, shared the family’s heartbreak, describing how Atul had never let his suffering show. He revealed that Atul had been repeatedly harassed by his wife, who filed multiple cases against him. According to his father, Atul had expressed frustration with the legal system, which he felt worked against him.

“He told us that the mediation courts do not follow the law or even the Supreme Court’s guidelines. He had to travel to Jaunpur from Bengaluru over 40 times. She kept filing charge after charge. He must have been frustrated but never let us feel that,” Pawan Kumar said.

The family learned about Atul’s death when he sent an email to his younger brother at around 1 a.m., confirming his intentions. His father added, *”It’s 100% true that what my son said about his wife and her family is correct. The system failed us, and that is why our son killed himself.”*

Atul’s Brother Speaks Out

Atul’s brother, Bikas Kumar, also spoke about the injustice, claiming that Indian laws favor women over men. He stated, “My brother’s wife filed a divorce case and framed multiple charges against him and our entire family. Every law in India is for women and not for men. My brother fought for this, but he left us.”

He urged President Droupadi Murmu and Prime Minister Narendra Modi to provide justice for Atul, stating, “If my brother is in the right, justice must be done. If not, show us the proof. There should be an investigation into the judge named in his suicide note.”

Friend Reveals Atul’s Struggles

Jackson, a close friend of Atul, revealed the immense stress his friend had been under due to the nine cases filed against him by his wife. Jackson explained that while Atul didn’t appear overtly depressed in the video, it was clear that he felt harassed by both his wife and the legal system.

He also shared details about how Atul had been supportive during his wife’s illness, going out of his way to care for her and their child when she contracted COVID-19. Jackson said, “His wife wasn’t taking her medication on time, which caused friction. Eventually, she left him with the baby, and he couldn’t even see his son.”

Jackson mentioned that Atul had recently learned about a court order requiring him to pay ₹40,000 per month in maintenance for his son, adding to his stress and feelings of helplessness.

The suicide has led to widespread public debate over men’s rights and the legal system’s treatment of men in India. Many people are demanding a thorough investigation into the allegations of bias, legal harassment, and the actions of those involved in Atul’s case. The incident has raised critical questions about the protection of men’s rights and the need for a more balanced and fair legal system for all.

UP Police File FIR Against Atul Subhash’s Wife And Family for Abetment of Suicide

In this regard, on 10 December 2024, the Uttar Pradesh police registered a case against the wife of Atul Subhash and family members for abetment of suicide. An FIR has been filed against four individuals, including Atul’s wife, Nikita Singhania; her mother, Nisha Singhania; her brother, Anurag Singhania; and her uncle, Sushil Singhania. The FIR, based on a complaint by Atul’s brother, Bikas Kumar, was lodged at the Marathahalli police station in Bengaluru. The charges include Section 108 (abetment of suicide) and Section 3(5) (joint criminal liability) of the BNS.

According to the complaint, Atul married Nikita Singhania in 2019, and the couple had a child. It is alleged that after their separation, the four accused filed false charges against Atul and demanded Rs 3 crore as a settlement. Furthermore, the complaint claims that Nikita demanded Rs 30 lakh from Atul to allow him to see their four-year-old son. The family alleges that Atul’s suicide was the result of ongoing mental and physical harassment by his wife, her relatives, and others involved in the case.

Atul Subhash, who worked for a private firm in Bengaluru, left behind a 24-page suicide note, detailing the emotional and psychological distress he endured due to marital issues, multiple cases filed against him, and harassment by his wife and her family. Police found Atul’s body hanging in his residence in the Manjunath Layout area, within the Marathahalli police jurisdiction. A placard reading “Justice is due” was discovered in the room where he ended his life. Investigations are ongoing.

Critics suggest that the tragic death of Atul Subhash highlights a broader systemic issue within India’s legal and judicial framework, particularly regarding gender biases. They argue that the laws, often perceived as favoring women, are passed by Parliament and legislatures, which perpetuate gender imbalances.

Additionally, there is concern over the shift from the Anglo-Saxon principle of “presumption of innocence” to the Napoleonic “presumption of guilt,” which has become ingrained in Indian jurisprudence, particularly in cases involving financial fraud, terrorism, and tax laws.

While the judiciary has made efforts to mitigate these issues, critics contend that existing laws limit judges and cannot fully address the underlying biases. Another major issue highlighted is the lack of accountability for individuals who make false accusations, as there are rarely prosecutions for perjury.

This failure to penalize false accusers, along with the police’s reluctance to act on such cases, discourages deterrence. Critics argue that there should be mandatory perjury prosecutions and stronger penalties for lawyers who facilitate such actions. Furthermore, the endemic corruption in police forces and the lack of critical thinking in society have contributed to the abuse of legal processes.

They also criticize the state of jurisprudence in India, where repeated violations of legal principles often go unpunished, though some judges manage to protect men from unjust prosecution. Ultimately, critics maintain that merely tinkering with laws won’t resolve these issues; instead, comprehensive reforms—clearer laws, better judicial education, improved accountability, and significant police reforms—are necessary to address the root causes of these systemic failures.

Subscribe to our channels on Telegram, WhatsApp, and Instagram and get the best stories of the day delivered to you personally.